Every formation service page is designed to make you compare one number: the base price. So let us start there, and then run the two premium names everyone ends up choosing between, Firstbase at $399 and Stripe Atlas at $500, through the seven checks that actually decide whether you overpaid. Check one is where a price sits in the field. Across the 66 services in the FormationCompare dataset that publish a base price, the median is $383. Six services form companies free, 16 charge under $100, and a full 27 charge $500 or more. Firstbase at $399 sits just above the median in the $300 to $499 band. Atlas at $500 stands at the floor of the top band, which makes it look like the expensive option until you read what the $500 includes.

Bar chart of base prices across 66 formation services: 6 are free, 16 charge $1 to $99, 6 charge $100 to $299, 11 charge $300 to $499 including Firstbase at $399, and 27 charge $500 or more including Stripe Atlas at $500; median base price $383
Source: FormationCompare dataset, 78 services, verified Sep 13, 2026. Sixty-six of the 78 publish a base price; the rest quote on request.

1. Renewal pricing, in writing. The base price is a first date; the renewal is the marriage. Atlas renews at $100 a year, Firstbase at $299. The discount end is worse: Bizee's $0 becomes $119 a year, and ZenBusiness's $99 becomes $199 a year. Screenshot the renewal page before you pay anything. 2. EIN handling without an SSN. If you are foreign, this is the whole product. Atlas includes the EIN; Firstbase includes expedited EIN setup; doola runs a specialized process for no-SSN founders. Bizee's process assumes US applicants. 3. State choice. Atlas is Delaware only, which is perfect if Delaware is your answer and useless if you decided on Wyoming. Firstbase offers Delaware or Wyoming. A service that cannot file in your state is not cheap at any price.

4. Registered agent: bundled or bolted on? Atlas includes a first-year registered agent. Firstbase requires it separately, at $299 a year, which is exactly its renewal figure, so the honest Firstbase price is $399 plus an agent from day one. Some free formation deals elsewhere are really $200 a year agent subscriptions in disguise. 5. What is excluded. Operating agreements run $40 to $99 as add-ons at Bizee and ZenBusiness; Atlas includes founder stock documents and Firstbase includes bylaws and a stock purchase agreement, but business licenses and tax filings are excluded almost everywhere. 6. Refund policy. Can you cancel before the state filing? After it? State fees, once paid to the state, are gone regardless of the service's policy. 7. Support quality. Read recent reviews, not the homepage. Formation.legal's DIY guide exists because support at the big platforms got thin, and the moment you need support is the moment something is already wrong.

Run the firstbase vs stripe atlas pair through those seven and a pattern emerges. Atlas wins on renewal price, included agent and included EIN, and loses on state choice and on everything that happens after formation, because Atlas is a starting gun, not a back office. Firstbase wins on state choice and post-incorporation documents, and loses on the agent add-on that quietly doubles its yearly cost. Neither is the cheapest way to own an LLC over three years once renewals are counted, and both are defensible buys for the founders they were built for. If you want a lower-cost data point for contrast, IncorpTrack charges $49 plus the state fee with EIN and banking help included, and no renewal trap because there is no subscription.

Firstbase vs Stripe Atlas: 7 Things to Check Before Paying for an LLC Formation Service
Image via Wikimedia Commons

Put the pair on a three-year clock and the seven checks turn into arithmetic. Atlas: $500 plus two renewals at $100 is $700 of service money over three years. Firstbase: $399 plus two renewals at $299 is $997, and that assumes the dataset's $299 renewal figure covers the agent you had to add. Same two companies, same three years, a $297 gap that the base prices alone, $399 against $500, point in exactly the wrong direction. That inversion is the single most common mistake in formation shopping, and it is why check one asks for renewal pricing before check anything else. A founder who forms once and keeps the company for a decade will pay the renewal ten times and the base price once.

Check all seven and the cheapest option usually changes. The most expensive formation is the one you pay for twice: once to the service that bundled wrong, and again to the service you migrate to in year two.

Run your own numbers

The True Cost Calculator applies check one and check four automatically, adding renewals and state fees to any base price over three years. Run Firstbase and Atlas through it with your state selected, then spend your energy on the other five checks.

Sources: Doola, Stripe Atlas, and the FormationCompare dataset of 78 formation services, verified September 13, 2026.